What if, I tell you that – if procreating women are allowed in Sabarimala, this place will become a sex tourism spot? Hold on to your thoughts if you think I have become insane and need immediate psychiatrist attention. This is in fact not something I can tell, as I don’t have enough theological knowledge about either the Tantrik Philosophy or Brahmacharya. This was told by the head priest (Tantri) of the Sabarimalai temple board recently. Obviously, the media did not seek any explanation of the same from him, nor did they do any research to understand what he really said/meant. Media immediately projected this matter as THE biggest form of misogyny (I found it more hateful to male devotees though). But before you even get to understand that, you need to understand a few basic things about Tantrik Philosophy.
For the last several days, we are seeing a huge debate about women’s entry into the Sabarimala temple. Devotees of Lord Ayyappa were so angry with the Supreme Court order, that they came onto the streets to protest and prevented women activists and journalists from entering the temple. As a non-Ayyappa devotee myself, I have become immensely curious to understand why women (of certain ages) are not allowed in the temple and a study led me to the news above. Others are talking about the relatively simple explanation that Lord Ayyappa is a celibate, so women are not allowed, is also not enough. Apparently, what the head priest (Tantri) of Sabarimalai has said, may seem to be hilarious, insane, misogynistic but before we conclude anything we need to understand the whole concept of keeping women out and why it is the women devotees who are spearheading the ban.
How Hindu Temples Work
Hindu temples are places of worship with a difference. Unlike other religions, every Hindu deity has a History to tell. Even the same deity in different places may be worshipped in a different manner. So, the story of a deity needs to be understood first before even worshipping that deity. That is why not everyone needs to worship every deity but if one wants to worship a deity, one needs to essentially follow the rules of worship.
This is true for every religion. But since Hindus have innumerous deities that no one Hindu person may even know, it is important to understand the deity and the rules of worship before we even attempt to discuss certain customs.
At Least 8 Indian Temples Ban Entry of Men
In this argument very often a mention of 8 different temples that ban entry of men is coming. And none of us MRAs will ever raise this as an issue, as we respect the culture and rules of worship in those places. This is not even a gender discrimination issue. Not every ritual we have can actually have men and women equally participate because every ritual, every temple has some specific significance. If we don’t honor that, we don’t honor the custom and hence no longer remain relevant to follow that faith (say Hinduism).
Hence the temples that ban entry of men will not even feature in this discussion. But now let’s try to understand the legend behind the Sabarimala Lord Ayyappa temple as a next step.
The HiStory of Lord Ayappa
At this juncture, it is important to understand that there are many other Ayyappa temples in India, where Lord Ayyappa is worshipped in many forms but here we will understand the story of Lord Ayyappa of Sabarimala in short. More information is available here.
According to History, Lord Ayyappa has his human incarnation as the son of Raja Rajasekhara, the King of Pandalam, Kerala. His name was Manikantan (Mani – gemstone, Kantan – wearer around the neck). The King got him on the banks of river Pampa, adopted him as their son and accepted him as the prince (Yuvaraja) by them.
Once Manikantan killed a demoness Mahishi and then a beautiful young lady appeared. She was cursed to become Mahishi. After coming out of the curse she wanted to marry him.
But since he has taken eternal Brahmacharya (called Naishitika Brahmacharya) he could not marry her but promised to marry her when new pilgrims stop coming to him. He told the King about the process of his worship and the results his worshippers would get (Bhutanatha Upakhanyam). Accordingly, the king constructed the temple and next to that another temple was constructed for the Devi, who is now worshipped as Maalikapurathamma.
Austerity To Be Observed by the Ayyappans
At this point, we also need to understand the process of deity worship at Sabarimala. The essential part of deity worship at Sabarimala is keeping penance for at least 41 days before coming to the temple. The penance includes but not limited to simple living, absolute cleanliness and holy thoughts. Since the deity is a celibate, these pilgrims need to maintain absolute celibacy for these 41 days. The devotee needs to maintain the absolute purity of his body and mind during this time. Total abstinence from all vices like alcohol, tobacco, non-vegetarian food is a must. Personal adornments, hair cutting, shaving etc. is also not permitted.
The process of keeping penance is of paramount importance here. One needs to achieve high levels of purity of the body and mind before one can go for the Darshan.
Cleanliness of Body and Mind
It is important to understand that in Hinduism it is absolutely important to be clean both from inner self and outer self before any deity worship. Even men, who are not properly clean cannot perform deity worship. That is why in public places of worship like temples, not every man visiting there has the ‘right’ to touch the deity. The reason Brahmins follow a certain lifestyle and follow certain procedures before any deity worship is this.
Why Procreating Women Are Not Allowed
The popular belief that menstruating women are unclean (because menstruation can happen anytime) and hence are not allowed into the shrine may not be true. One argument being, there is a alight chance that women below 10 and more than 50 may also have a chance of menstruation bleeding. Actually, this is what is presented during the court arguments as well. So, it is important to understand that this age bar was placed by the Kerala Govt. by an ordinance and even the respondents of the Sabarimala PIL feel it was arbitrary and it should have been based on procreation ability of women. But the question is how can you even check if one woman has procreating ability without setting an age limit is a question.
Celibate Nature of the God
The most popular belief for the ban of women is more to maintain the celibate nature of God. As one of the prominent rules of performing Naishitika Brahmacharya is to keep as much distance possible from women. Even Sr’la Prabhupada during his Sannyasa life used to keep maximum distance from women, he even stopped meeting his own sister alone. The level of stricture for a God is to be observed at a higher level.
But the question is, if he has attained the status of a God, then how is he perturbed by the presence of procreating women? And why only he is disturbed by procreating women and not women who are younger or older in age?
This question becomes stronger when we know it was the Kerala Govt. and not the Hindu scriptures that have set the age limit. Advct. J Sai Deepak, who argued in favor of the respondents in the SC PIL said in an interview that the Tantra Philosophy puts enormous importance to the sexual energy and hence only procreating women are banned from entry. There comes the argument of the choice of Lord Ayyappa, too. His choice of observing his celibacy as found in scriptures of the temple was that he wanted to keep a distance from women. So, if that was the choice, then why any woman is allowed to enter into the temple?
Since we now know that this age group was specified by the Kerala Govt. by an ordinance, there seems to be a high chance that it was more to safeguard itself from the constitutional provision of equality. But unfortunately, this is challenged again on the same ground.
So, we understand that if the celibate nature of the God Ayyappa was the main concern then all women should have been barred, but it is not so. Why?
Respect For Maalikapurathamma
Some people say, women voluntarily don’t enter the temple to show respect for Maalikapurathamma who is waiting outside the temple to marry Lord Ayyappa once new devotees stop coming to him. However, with some women still going to meet Lord Ayyappa, this argument also seems partly valid.
Why The Head Priest said What He Said
Now if you read the arguments above, you will know none of the above explanations actually can explain allowing entry to a certain group of women and banning entry for some others. When the Lord Ayyappa wanted to apply more strictures upon him, why should any woman be allowed? Here the reason given by the head priest of the temple comes into focus.
Not only the head priest, but there are other Hindu sages said, that if procreating women are allowed to enter Sabarimala Ayyappa temple, then “it will harm them.” But their voices are not heard very often or get suppressed by the popular theory that “menstruating women” are not allowed, which is not true.
So, to understand the nature of the harm it can cause to women I spoke with some Hindu Gurus. From those discussions, what I understood is this –
Tantrik forms of Temples have enormous energy inside. Since this deity is eternal Brahmachari, the energies inside the sanctum are enormous, when Ayyappans pay a visit to the god, their energy also gets a part of it. This collective energy can be so huge that it not only harms women with childbearing capability, this energy may also impregnate them. But even to accommodate this energy within, women will need tremendous yogic powers, else this will harm them for good.
There are many stories in Hindu Puranas where women just offered prayers to their god for a child and gave birth to children. Hindu Shashtras had many such instances. Kunti and Madri both gave birth to children by a boon given to them. Karna was also born from the grace of the God Sun. So, we understand that Hindu mythology has many such examples of children taking birth with any intercourse.
Since fertile women will be in the mood of procreating, that is the time when their body will be more conducive to procreation. They will attract this energy towards them which will result in what the head priest just hinted that led to controversy. This will also reduce the overall energy of the place and hence will affect all pilgrims as they will not get their desired results.
What Some Others Say
Some other gurus however say a different thing. They say, what the head Tantri has said has literal meaning than theological one. They said, a temple is not a tourist spot and it is for bhakti. We need to essentially leave our material desires behind and enter the temple. There are other temples where the temples see lovers making love inside the temple and in the compund. There are instances where new brothels came up around ISKCON temple in Kolkata. They say, we need to maintain sanctity of temples, else they will become lovemaking places and the desired outcome of spritual advancement not possible.
How The Energy Can Harm Women
At this juncture, it is important to understand how the energy generated from the Sadhana can actually harm women.
If you remember the rules of penance I discussed earlier, before coming to Sabarimala, every devotee must observe complete abstinence and reorient that sexual energy to raise the spiritual energy. In both men and women, our sexual energy flows downwards, and spiritual energy flows upwards. For men, celibacy can improve and store this energy in their body. In men, the energy flows in the form of semen and in women in the form of menstrual flow. The flow of semen can be controlled but not the flow of menstrual blood. So, when men observe penance and Brahmacharya, their sexual energy enhances. They can store this energy in their body. That is why Brahmachari men have better sexual powers as they can control their sexual power well. So, Brahmacharya is actually beneficial for men.
On the other hand, women have a natural monthly cycle of downward flow of blood out of their body. This is the natural process of eliminating the old blood and refilling their body with fresh blood. If this natural process is disrupted by forcing their energy upwards, their downward menstruating flow will disrupt.
The spiritual energy (read ‘Teja’) in the temple is so much that normal women will not be able to endure it. Also, since one needs to visit the temple every year for 18 years, repeatedly practicing Brahmacharya (or any yoga in an inverted position that pulls their energy towards their head) they may lose their potency permanently. If women lose their potency, then life will come to a standstill. This is the real reason women are not allowed in the temple.
What Women Have Experienced
At this point it is important to discuss why women from the neighborhood of Sabarimala temple always avoided going to the temple before the ban. Sinu Joseph, who is a renowned menstrual hygeine educator from Mythri, a feminist NGO discussed real experiences of women in temples and how different temples have altered women’s menstruation cycles.
Read here – What Menstruating Women Experienced in Sabarimala
Discussion of Rights
As always, some atheist and non-believer Hindus who are non-Ayyappa devotees are discussing the issue of the right to pray in public places. However, we need to understand that this temple is not run by the state to implement any of the rights discussed. It is learnt that the annual funds (51 lakhs) it receives through the Kerala Govt, is actually the rent paid to the temple by the Union of India. The history, in short, is when the Travancore Princely states joined the Indian Union in the year 1922 that was the time it was decided. So, the state or Indian Union can’t interfere into the religious matters there. So, no rights can be implemented by the Union of India. The sole right that should prevail in the temple is that the right of Lord Ayyappa, as this is His house.
Why Ban Entry? Why Not Let Women Decide?
Another question that is frequently asked is why ban women’s entry into Sabarimala temple? Why not leave entry to women’s choice?
One strong point against leaving it women’s choice is when women of reproducing capability enter the temple and absorb the energy in them, they reduce the overall energy that can benefit of other devotees. This way, other devotees will not get their desired result.
There is another point that we can’t leave such decisions on people who are ignorant about ill-effects. Only the people who are knowledgeable about the subject has the right to decide. Other ignorant people may end up harming them more because of their ignorance rather than anything else. Also, as a society we have the responsibility to ensure that every social ritual have a social welfare attached to it. As Hindu Shashtras promote saving women for saving humanity (because of their reproductive power), anything which follows shashtra can’t be done to the contrary.
Paradox of ’33-Koti’ Hindu Gods
Very often we Hindus think ’33-Koti’ means 33 Crore or 330 Million. Even I used to think the same until recently. But that is not true. After my discussions I came to know ’33-Koti’ in Sanskrit language does not translate to 33-crore in English. Rather the explanation is given below –
These 33-परमपूज्य or highly respected gods are –
8-Vasu, 11-Rudra, and 12-Aaditya, 1-Indra and 1-Prajaapati. (In some Hindu Purana instead of Indra and Prajapati, Ashwinikumardway is mentioned.
8 Vasus are ~ Air, Ether, Moon, Earth, Water, Fire, Sun, and Star.
They are called Vasus, because they are abode of all that lives, moves or exists. (also mentioned in Mahabharat, 1/66/18)
11 Rudras ~ First ten Pranas (Praana, Apaana, Kurma, Krikal, Devadutta, Vyaana, Samaana, Udaana, Naag and Dhananjaya) i.e. nervauric forces which live in the human body.
Human soul is the the eleventh one. These are called ‘Rudras’ because when they desert the body, it becomes dead and the relationships of the deceased, consequently, begin to weep. (Rudra means one who makes a person to weep)
12 Adityaas —the twelve months of a year called Adityaas, they cause the lapse of the term of existence of each object or being.
1. Indra which is also known as the (all-pervading) electricity, as it is productive of great force.
1. Prajaapati , also called the “Yajna” because it benefits mankind by the purification of air, water, rain and vegetables and because it aids the development of various arts, and in it the honor is accorded to the learned and the wise.
*Some say this as only 33-types of Hindu God. However, only mention of ‘types’ make it disrespectful for a God. So, परमपूज्य is mentioned. You can worship any other (like we Hindus really don’t have any dearth of god, but the creator of the universe is one. So, Hindus also believe in one God.
It is important to understand that there is no society or system where everyone can have absolute equality in all spheres. This is certainly not enforceable in matters of religion. Also, Hindus need to understand that Hinduism is so vast that we hardly know this religion properly. If Hinduism survived the test of time, that is because of its inherent potentials. If you are a Hindu, respect your religion, else no one else will. Once, we Hindus lose our culture in the name of liberalism and fake equality, then we will lose our identity.
In the case of Sabarimala Ayyappa, as you understand, mindless equality can actually harm Hindu women and take away their reproductive ability. Don’t even fall for such feminist traps.
[This is a part of Vedic India Series to understand Indian customs.
All articles under Vedic India can be found – here]
Written nicely and with an approach that very few have made public in writing.
i want to ask a question where is the logical reason
If you did not find the logical reason yet…that itself is a laughing matter. May be you need to improve your English and logical reasoning skills..
thank you i will surely improve my english..but i still couldnot find and logical reason
I liked your well researched post and the fact that you have chosen to speak on a matter that’s of importance. Your arguments are logical and I agree that Hinduism is complex. That is why there is also a section that sees this as unfair to women. I am not adding any feminist angle to this but more a thought.
If I think of Hanuman ji – women were not allowed to touch or worship him too. Just another example of the religion.
Well written post! While on this please read my post – Sabarimala and the tradition conundrum! https://wp.me/p1dZc2-yu
Feedback most welcome!
So these men are of the thought that stopping women from entering the temple will stop them from thinking about the Lord. What an ideology?
Can those men stop women from thinking about the Lord too??
Instead of addressing their own mindlessness and inadequacies they are thinking that the Lord is inadequate to handle his own self.
There is an eastern phenomena for such thinking mindset – Agnani meaning knowledge-less and that’s the level those men are holding.
It’s high time those men who are trying to stop women from entering the temple unlearn themselves and then think about whether they themselves have the right mindset to enter the temple and then so see the Lord in the temple.
Where on earth did you get these points? “So these men are of the thought that stopping women from entering the temple will stop them from thinking about the Lord.” – Are you in your mind? Or you are a bot just randomly commenting? Do you even understand what your comment really portray about you?
Another mindless idiot hypocrite spotted 😆😅😂🤣! He( as mentioned in the name) is a random brainwashed, feminist minded guy ( basically opportunist) who haven’t even gone through your article and just barking because his ego got triggered! I get amused when feminists or similiar mentality people get a bashing answer opposite to their propaganda! Has he ever bothered to question why 8temples restricted men from entering? Answer is no. The bloody hypocrisy of “…Equality…” is getting exposed day by day and their naked misandry is getting exposed. 😜😜😜😜 well that’s a good thing.
Well explained, I want to stand up & 👏 clap.